Comments for Islamiology http://islamiology.wordpress.com The similitude of knowledge without application is a laden donkey Wed, 02 Dec 2009 06:49:21 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 Comment on Abdullah ibn Masood: Whoever wishes to follow a good example should follow the dead… by barbara http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/11/09/abdullah-ibn-masood-whoever-wishes-to-follow-a-good-example-should-follow-the-dead/#comment-356 barbara Wed, 02 Dec 2009 06:49:21 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/11/09/abdullah-ibn-masood-whoever-wishes-to-follow-a-good-example-should-follow-the-dead/#comment-356 and what to do if i do not want to call myself salafi, but i want to follow them? i do want be good, but i am not strong enought sometimes. and what to do or think if i had muslim friend converted like me and we talked bedly about others and everytime i felt so bad about it than i told her that its wrong so she that is someone is planning bad for her she can say that... so i told her that better we do not talk, than after sometime she asked why and why so i told her that its because of it, she called me ignorant because we both were talking about pplz, i told her that i regret that. than i talked somethink not nice to her in public because i though she attacked country of my husband that they do not help palestinians, than i found out that she attacked only govermnet but why did she said that in public? why she do not say anythink about other countries or her husband? so i sorry her and she nothing. i felt so quilty about all what happend so i sorry her by my friend to tell her because she said to remove her address from my friends list. and she did not answeer. what should i do or think as a muslim? i feel i did good by sorry, but she is so unfair and i do not feel good... what should i do as salafi will do? and what to do if i do not want to call myself salafi, but i want to follow them? i do want be good, but i am not strong enought sometimes.
and what to do or think if i had muslim friend converted like me and we talked bedly about others and everytime i felt so bad about it than i told her that its wrong so she that is someone is planning bad for her she can say that… so i told her that better we do not talk, than after sometime she asked why and why so i told her that its because of it, she called me ignorant because we both were talking about pplz, i told her that i regret that. than i talked somethink not nice to her in public because i though she attacked country of my husband that they do not help palestinians, than i found out that she attacked only govermnet but why did she said that in public? why she do not say anythink about other countries or her husband? so i sorry her and she nothing. i felt so quilty about all what happend so i sorry her by my friend to tell her because she said to remove her address from my friends list. and she did not answeer. what should i do or think as a muslim? i feel i did good by sorry, but she is so unfair and i do not feel good… what should i do as salafi will do?

]]> Comment on Eating: Difference between Believer and Disbelievers by barbara http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/03/eating-difference-between-believer-and-disbelievers/#comment-355 barbara Wed, 02 Dec 2009 06:33:31 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/03/eating-difference-between-believer-and-disbelievers/#comment-355 will be there really fire? my friend whi is muslim longer then me asaid that it is only said that it is a fire, because pplz afray of it, but it is not mean tah... and she is a student of some woman who gives her lessons about islam. but will it be really fire and will it be for ever? will be there really fire? my friend whi is muslim longer then me asaid that it is only said that it is a fire, because pplz afray of it, but it is not mean tah… and she is a student of some woman who gives her lessons about islam.
but will it be really fire and will it be for ever?

]]> Comment on Prophet’s Sermon #30: Refreshment and Pleasure by asaffat http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2008/12/16/prophets-sermon-30-refreshment-and-pleasure/#comment-347 asaffat Thu, 12 Nov 2009 05:07:04 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2008/12/16/prophets-sermon-30-refreshment-and-pleasure/#comment-347 Assalam alaikum, These sermons are fabricated. Ibn Wa'dan is a liar. Assalam alaikum,

These sermons are fabricated. Ibn Wa’dan is a liar.

]]> Comment on The Prophet SAWS: On Dua and Qadr… by Hammad http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/the-prophet-saws-on-dua-and-qadr/#comment-346 Hammad Tue, 10 Nov 2009 07:48:10 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/the-prophet-saws-on-dua-and-qadr/#comment-346 Which one? There are two... Which one? There are two…

]]> Comment on The Prophet SAWS: On Dua and Qadr… by barbara http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/the-prophet-saws-on-dua-and-qadr/#comment-345 barbara Tue, 10 Nov 2009 07:22:21 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/the-prophet-saws-on-dua-and-qadr/#comment-345 I do not understand this hadith I do not understand this hadith

]]> Comment on Prophet SAWS on The Life Span of the Ummah… (We’re nearing the end) by Hammad http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-344 Hammad Mon, 09 Nov 2009 06:19:53 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-344 Asalam. Brother I'm not an expert, but from my understanding, the end of this world doesn't equal Judgement Day (of which only Allah SWT alone in his infinite wisdom has knowledge of.) Similarly, the beginning of this world doesn't equal the beginning of creation [as angels and jinns were created before humans and similarly they have to be destroyed after humans.] The hadith is referring to the lifespan of the Ummah of the Prophet SAWS. I don't understand why the Shaykh on IslamQA equated them and maybe if you are in touch with him you can clarify. Allah knows best. Asalam.

Brother I’m not an expert, but from my understanding, the end of this world doesn’t equal Judgement Day (of which only Allah SWT alone in his infinite wisdom has knowledge of.)

Similarly, the beginning of this world doesn’t equal the beginning of creation [as angels and jinns were created before humans and similarly they have to be destroyed after humans.]

The hadith is referring to the lifespan of the Ummah of the Prophet SAWS.

I don’t understand why the Shaykh on IslamQA equated them and maybe if you are in touch with him you can clarify.

Allah knows best.

]]> Comment on Prophet SAWS on The Life Span of the Ummah… (We’re nearing the end) by asaffat http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-343 asaffat Sun, 08 Nov 2009 13:02:10 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-343 Assalam alaikum, The hadith is talking about the ummah ending at that time, not the end of the world. As you may know, Islam will be lifted from the world such that a person would say, "I heard my elders saying 'Allah, Allah' but I don't know what it means." And that the Hour will be established on the worst of mankind. Given that an abundance of the signs have come to pass (women dressed but naked, arabs building lofty towers, etc) it is not far fetched that our ummah is very close to the end. Wa assalam alaikum Assalam alaikum,

The hadith is talking about the ummah ending at that time, not the end of the world. As you may know, Islam will be lifted from the world such that a person would say, “I heard my elders saying ‘Allah, Allah’ but I don’t know what it means.” And that the Hour will be established on the worst of mankind.

Given that an abundance of the signs have come to pass (women dressed but naked, arabs building lofty towers, etc) it is not far fetched that our ummah is very close to the end.

Wa assalam alaikum

]]> Comment on Prophet SAWS on The Life Span of the Ummah… (We’re nearing the end) by Ibrahim http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-342 Ibrahim Sun, 08 Nov 2009 12:00:25 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-342 Yes akhi you're right. But, weak ahadeeth that contradict shari'ah are not to be taken seriously, such as this one. I mean Imam al-Suyuti using this hadith pretty much pin points the time when the world will come to an end. Let me ask you. Do you positively believe that the world will end in 70 years since it's 1430 AH now? If so, then doesn't it go against Allah's saying that only He knows when the day of judgment will occur. Anyhow, your point is absolutely correct that the time is near, wAllahu a'lam. Yes akhi you’re right. But, weak ahadeeth that contradict shari’ah are not to be taken seriously, such as this one. I mean Imam al-Suyuti using this hadith pretty much pin points the time when the world will come to an end.

Let me ask you. Do you positively believe that the world will end in 70 years since it’s 1430 AH now? If so, then doesn’t it go against Allah’s saying that only He knows when the day of judgment will occur.

Anyhow, your point is absolutely correct that the time is near, wAllahu a’lam.

]]> Comment on Prophet SAWS on The Life Span of the Ummah… (We’re nearing the end) by Hammad http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-341 Hammad Sun, 08 Nov 2009 07:04:56 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-341 Jazakallah Khayr for the post. For the information of the Muslims, it is important to note what 'weak' hadith means and that it nonetheless still provides a valuable source of information and the majority of scholars permitted its usage and narrated the weak hadith themselves (as an example of this hadith). Many scholars prefer the usage of weak hadith over qiyas/analogy (Hanafis, Shafi's, etc.) Imam Bukhari used many weak narrations in his Adab al-Mufrad as well as Imam Muslim in his collection, as long as the narrator wasn't accused of lying or forging and they didn't have to do with Shariah rulings and promoted virtuous deeds. Imam Nawawi said: It is permissible to act (with caution) on such matters which are borne out of weak (Da’ef) Ahadeeth. If these hadith were good enough for the hadith masters and scholars of our deen... Jazakallah Khayr for the post.

For the information of the Muslims, it is important to note what ‘weak’ hadith means and that it nonetheless still provides a valuable source of information and the majority of scholars permitted its usage and narrated the weak hadith themselves (as an example of this hadith). Many scholars prefer the usage of weak hadith over qiyas/analogy (Hanafis, Shafi’s, etc.)

Imam Bukhari used many weak narrations in his Adab al-Mufrad as well as Imam Muslim in his collection, as long as the narrator wasn’t accused of lying or forging and they didn’t have to do with Shariah rulings and promoted virtuous deeds.

Imam Nawawi said: It is permissible to act (with caution) on such matters which are borne out of weak (Da’ef) Ahadeeth.

If these hadith were good enough for the hadith masters and scholars of our deen…

]]> Comment on Prophet SAWS on The Life Span of the Ummah… (We’re nearing the end) by Ibrahim http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-340 Ibrahim Sun, 08 Nov 2009 06:54:37 +0000 http://islamiology.wordpress.com/2009/10/16/prophet-saws-on-the-life-span-of-the-ummah-were-nearing-the-end/#comment-340 False hadith, akhi: http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/33689 False hadith, akhi: http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/33689

]]>